Se Habla Español

For Low Cost Car Insurance

833-700-0000

For Low Cost Car Insurance

833-700-0000

AAA Car Insurance vs Progressive vs GoAuto

Shopping for car insurance in Baton Rouge? With Louisiana ranking among the most expensive states for auto coverage, it’s important to compare your options carefully — especially if you want a policy that fits your budget, your driving habits, and your local risks.

In this in-depth comparison, we’ll break down three popular options for Baton Rouge drivers:

  • AAA Car Insurance

  • Progressive

  • GoAutoInsurance.com

We’ll look at pricing, coverage flexibility, local support, and what matters most for Louisiana drivers. Whether you’re a student, a working parent, or a high-risk driver, this guide will help you find the best insurance company for your needs in Baton Rouge.

Get a Quote

1. Overview: Who Are These Companies?

🛑 AAA Car Insurance

  • Known for roadside assistance and member perks

  • Offers insurance through regional affiliates

  • Traditional agent-based service

  • Generally middle-of-the-road pricing

🚗 Progressive

  • One of the largest national insurance brands

  • Focuses on online quotes, big-data pricing, and bundling

  • Known for discounts, especially for safe drivers

  • Pricing can vary widely based on credit, ZIP code, and risk profile

✅ GoAutoInsurance.com

  • Louisiana-based provider focused on low-cost coverage

  • No commission-based agents — direct pricing

  • Ideal for low-income, high-risk, or budget-conscious drivers

  • Local offices in Baton Rouge with real human support

2. Price Comparison in Baton Rouge

Driver ProfileAAA (Est.)Progressive (Est.)GoAuto (Est.)
25-year-old, clean record$135 – $165/mo$115 – $145/mo$85 – $110/mo
40-year-old with 1 accident$165 – $200/mo$145 – $185/mo$105 – $135/mo
22-year-old student$160 – $190/mo$140 – $170/mo$90 – $120/mo
55-year-old, low mileage$120 – $145/mo$105 – $130/mo$80 – $105/mo

Note: These are general estimates for Baton Rouge and can vary by ZIP code, credit score, vehicle type, and coverage selected.

3. Coverage Options

Feature/CompanyAAAProgressiveGoAutoInsurance.com
State Minimum Liability✅ Yes✅ Yes✅ Yes
Full Coverage Options✅ Yes✅ Yes✅ Yes
SR-22 / High-Risk Policies⚠️ Limited Availability✅ Available✅ Specialized & Easy
Non-Owner Insurance✅ Yes✅ Yes✅ Yes
Rideshare / Delivery Coverage❌ Not Available in All States✅ Available⚠️ Not Always Offered
Roadside Assistance✅ Yes (Membership)✅ Optional Add-on✅ Optional Add-on

4. Strengths & Weaknesses

AAA – Pros & Cons

Pros:

  • Excellent roadside assistance program

  • Well-known national brand

  • Local agents in some areas

Cons:

  • Membership fee required

  • Not the cheapest option for most Baton Rouge drivers

  • Less flexible payment plans

 

Progressive – Pros & Cons

Pros:

  • Online quote tools and bundling discounts

  • Snapshot® program rewards safe drivers

  • Broad coverage options, including rideshare

Cons:

  • Pricing may spike for poor credit or high-risk drivers

  • Rates in Baton Rouge can be high without discounts

  • Call center support can be inconsistent

 

GoAutoInsurance.com – Pros & Cons

Pros:

  • Among the lowest prices for liability and full coverage in Baton Rouge

  • No hidden fees or agent commissions

  • Local Baton Rouge offices with personal support

  • Flexible payment plans — including no-deposit options

  • Ideal for drivers with bad credit, no credit, or prior lapses

Cons:

  • Fewer discounts for bundling or multi-policy

  • Less suited for specialty coverage like luxury or commercial fleets

  • Limited out-of-state availability

5. Local Baton Rouge Support & Accessibility

CompanyLocal OfficesOnline Quote ToolIn-Person Support
AAA⚠️ Limited✅ Yes✅ With Membership
Progressive❌ None✅ Yes❌ Call Center Only
GoAutoInsurance.com✅ Multiple in Baton Rouge✅ Yes✅ Walk-ins Welcome

GoAuto is built for Louisiana drivers — not just Louisiana ZIP codes. That means real support, not national call centers. For Baton Rouge residents who want to talk to someone face-to-face, GoAuto has you covered.

6. Which Company Is Best for You?

Driver TypeBest Option
Low-income driverGoAutoInsurance.com
High-risk or SR-22 driverGoAutoInsurance.com
Tech-savvy with perfect creditProgressive
Classic car owner or member rewardsAAA
Need same-day, affordable coverageGoAutoInsurance.com
Want to talk to a local agentGoAutoInsurance.com

Final Thoughts: Choose the Right Fit for Your Budget and Lifestyle

Each insurer brings something different to the table, but for many Baton Rouge drivers, the choice comes down to affordability, flexibility, and local support.

If you’re looking for:

  • The lowest prices

  • Same-day coverage

  • No-deposit options

  • Support for high-risk drivers

  • Real, local customer service

👉 Then GoAutoInsurance is the best choice for Baton Rouge drivers.

Get a Free Quote Today

Compare prices and get covered fast — no long forms, no pressure.


Contact GoAuto today for a free, instant quote and find out how much you could save in Baton Rouge.

Get a Quote

For low cost car insurance

833-700-0000